Not Guilty Verdict
Intent to Distribute Cocaine — Not Guilty
Intent to Distribute CocaineMilwaukee County
ResultAttorney Nicole Muller secures another not guilty verdict.
Case Dismissed
Conspiracy to Distribute Marijuana — Dismissed
Conspiracy to Distribute MarijuanaFederal District
ResultCase dismissed after the government could not meet its burden of proving, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant committed the crime.
Case Dismissed
Intent to Distribute Heroin — Dismissed
Possession w/ Intent to Distribute HeroinRacine County
ResultCase dismissed; the prosecutor was unable to gather enough evidence to convince a jury beyond a reasonable doubt.
Case Dismissed
Possession of THC & Cocaine — Dismissed After Illegal Search
THC (2nd), Cocaine (2nd), ParaphernaliaRacine
ResultCase dismissed after the judge granted the defense motion suppressing the evidence due to an illegal search.
Case Dismissed
Drug Paraphernalia, Cocaine & THC — Dismissed
Paraphernalia, Cocaine, THCKenosha
ResultCase dismissed after a defense offer of proof that the defendant was neither present nor responsible for the controlled substances found in the defendant's apartment.
Charges Dismissed
Felony Delivery Charges — Dismissed After Treatment
Felony Delivery of Cocaine & Non-NarcoticsJefferson County
Facts: One felony count of delivering cocaine (oxycontin) and one felony count of delivering a Schedule I, II or III non-narcotic, both as a party to a crime. The client admitted involvement in a full statement after a hand-to-hand sale to an undercover detective, and faced 15 years in prison.
ResultDeferred Prosecution Agreement. Case dismissed entirely following 12 months of drug treatment and community service.
Case Dismissed
OWI 1st & Marijuana Possession — Illegal Stop, Motion Granted
OWI 1st, Marijuana, ParaphernaliaVillage of Fox Point
Facts: The client, who is Black, was driving in an all-white suburb at 2:30 a.m. after dropping off a friend. Police stopped him after he came to a complete stop at a flashing yellow light. Squad video showed his driving was perfect, and a motion to suppress was filed because it is not illegal to stop at a flashing yellow. The client faced 24 months license revocation, $1,900 in fines, and 1 year county jail on the drug charges.
ResultDismissed. Motion granted.
Conviction Reversed
Felony Conviction Reversed — Upheld by the Wisconsin Supreme Court
Fourth Amendment SearchWalworth CountyWI Court of AppealsWI Supreme Court
Facts: Police searched the client's residence, a separate building on property owned by his father-in-law, on the father-in-law's permission, over the objections of the client and his wife. The defense argued police lacked the right to search under the Fourth Amendment doctrine of "apparent authority."
ResultThe Wisconsin Court of Appeals agreed and reversed the felony conviction, and the Wisconsin Supreme Court upheld the reversal.
Sentence Reduced
Possession of THC & Cocaine (3rd Offense) — One Year Probation
THC & Cocaine, 3rd OffenseFederal District Court
ResultDefendant received only one year of probation.
Charges Reduced
Anonymous-Tip Search Warrant Challenged — Cocaine & Amphetamine Charges Dismissed
Cocaine, THC, Amphetamines/LSD/PsilocinKenosha
Facts: The search warrant was issued on the word of an anonymous tipster who failed to identify any particular wrongful acts by the client. A motion to suppress was filed based on the illegal search. The DA had asked for lengthy jail time before the motion was filed.
ResultPlea to a THC charge with 3 years probation; the possession of cocaine and amphetamine charges were dismissed.
Charges Reduced
Felony Drug Charges Dismissed, Then Refiled — Plea to Reduced Charges
Felony Drug ChargesWalworth2004 · Refiled 2005
Facts: All charges were dismissed in July 2004. The DA refiled a year later, in February 2005.
ResultClient pled guilty to 1 count of misdemeanor possession of THC, possession of amphetamine/LSD/psilocybin (2nd offense), and possession with intent to deliver psilocybin.
Charges Reduced · No Prison
Marijuana Delivery to an Undercover Officer — 10 Months Huber
Manufacture/Deliver THC (>200–1000g)Washington County
Facts: One count of manufacture/delivery of THC and two counts of possession of THC, with up to 6 years 7 months and an $11,500 fine at stake. The client sold 2 lbs. of marijuana to an undercover officer in a recorded transaction. The State refused to reveal its informant's identity; after numerous demands, the DA reduced its offer from 3 years prison to an amended charge of misdemeanor possession.
Result10 months Huber (work release) and 3 years probation.
Charges Reduced · Expunged
Three Possession Cases — Probation, Then Expungement
Possession of THC & ParaphernaliaOzaukee County
Facts: Within 5 months, the client was charged in three separate cases of possession of THC and drug paraphernalia, all based on traffic stops, and faced 18 months in jail.
ResultOne count of possession of THC dismissed entirely; 12 months probation, concurrent, on the other two. After successful completion of probation, all convictions were expunged and the client has no criminal record.
Felony Counts Dismissed
Selective Prosecution Challenge — Two of Three Felony Counts Dismissed
3 Felony Counts, Delivering CocaineWashington County
Facts: Three felony counts of delivering cocaine within 1,000 feet of a school, with up to 50 years in prison and a $500,000 fine at stake. All were hand-to-hand buys by the same undercover officer, and the DA waited 18 months to charge the client and 40 other Hispanics. The defense argued selective prosecution, noting that charges against Hispanics increased 2000% after this officer joined the drug unit, and found multiple witnesses who would have testified that the officer routinely took drugs with them and committed other crimes. The DA's first offer was 20 years prison, later reduced to 12 years after the defense filed motions. After the defense filed a formal complaint with the Department of Justice and a private criminal complaint against the officer, the case settled.
ResultTwo felony counts of delivering cocaine dismissed. Sentenced to probation and 12 months work release on the third count.
Prior results do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future case. Every case is unique and is evaluated on its own facts. The above are illustrative outcomes handled by Birdsall Muller LLC.